Home > On PM Motor > Permanent Magnet vs Induction Motor: Torque, Losses, Material

Permanent Magnet vs Induction Motor: Torque, Losses, Material

2025-10-10 11:50:33

By

    Share to:

Table of Contents

    magnet motor1

    Motors are at the center of almost every industrial setup. They run pumps in water plants, fans in textile factories, conveyors in mines, and compressors in workshops. For a long time, the induction motor was the main choice. It is strong, widely available, and dependable. But now the magnet motor—often called a permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM)—is getting more attention.

    Why is this happening? The answer is tied to three things: torque, losses, and material. In this article, we take a close look at how these two motor types compare.

    Torque Performance

    Startup Torque

    Induction motors produce torque through induction. The stator’s magnetic field creates current inside the rotor, and this current makes the rotor turn. The downside is that at startup, induction motors pull a very high inrush current—sometimes five to seven times higher than rated. Even so, their starting torque is not always strong. Heavy equipment may struggle to start without help from soft starters or other devices.

    Magnet motors behave differently. The rotor has built-in magnets. That means torque is ready right away. They can provide high starting torque—three to five times rated torque—without stressing the power grid. In real life, this is useful for conveyors, compressors, or textile machines that must start under load.

    Running Torque at Different Speeds

    Induction motor: Needs slip to run, so torque and efficiency change with load. At very low speeds, performance can fall.

    Magnet motor: Runs in sync with the stator field. Torque stays stable across a wide speed range.

    For industries that use variable frequency drives (VFDs), this steady torque makes PMSMs a better fit.

    Losses and Efficiency

    Where Energy Is Lost

    Induction motors lose power in several ways:

    • Heat in the rotor bars (copper or aluminum).

    • Slip losses, since the rotor never fully catches up with the field.

    • Extra current drawn just to build the field.

    Magnet motors avoid most of this. The permanent magnets in the rotor create the field directly. No extra current is needed, so less energy is wasted as heat.

    Efficiency Range

    • Induction motors: Usually 85–92% efficient at rated load.

    • Magnet motors: Often 90–97% efficient, and they keep high efficiency across 25–120% load.

    That difference sounds small, but in factories where motors run day and night, it adds up. In air compressors, for example, PMSM systems have been shown to cut energy use by up to 50%.

    Material Factors

    Rotor Design

    Induction motors use a rotor made of laminated steel with aluminum or copper bars. It’s simple and strong, but it depends on induced current.
    Magnet motors use rare-earth materials like neodymium-iron-boron (NdFeB) inside the rotor. These magnets provide a powerful field without pulling extra current.

    Size and Weight

    Because of the strong magnetic field, PMSMs can deliver more torque in a smaller body. On average, they are about 35% smaller and 40% lighter than a similar induction motor. This is helpful when machines have little room, such as textile spinning frames or air compressor housings.

    Heat and Service Life

    Induction motors run hotter. PMSMs, with fewer losses, stay cooler. Tests show temperature rise can be 20K lower. A cooler motor protects insulation and extends life.

    Side-by-Side Comparison

    Feature Induction Motor Permanent Magnet Motor (PMSM)
    Startup Torque High inrush current, modest torque High torque, low current draw
    Efficiency 85–92%, drops at low load 90–97%, steady at wide loads
    Losses Rotor + slip + magnetizing current Minimal, no rotor current
    Power Factor <0.9, needs compensation 0.95+ without extra devices
    Size & Weight Larger, heavier Smaller, lighter by 35–40%
    Heat Rise Higher, more stress on insulation Cooler by ~20K
    Maintenance More frequent, bearings and brushes Lower, fewer wear parts

    Industrial Applications

    Air Compressors

    PMSMs are widely used in compressor systems. With direct drive, there are no belts or gears, which saves power. Energy cuts of 40–50% have been reported.

    Textile Machines

    Magnet motors give precise speed and smoother operation. In weaving or spinning, that translates into better product quality and less vibration.

    Water Treatment

    Stable torque and cooler operation mean pumps can run longer without overheating. This lowers costs and reduces downtime.

    Mining Conveyors

    Traditional induction motor setups often need a reducer. PMSMs allow direct drive, cutting down oil changes, vibration, and maintenance work.

    magnet motor2

    Example in Practice

    A textile mill in eastern China struggled with rising power bills. Their induction motors were reliable but inefficient. After replacing them with PMSMs, the mill reported about 20% energy savings. Workers also noticed quieter machines and less vibration. Although the new motors cost more at the start, the plant recovered the cost in less than two years.

    Qingdao Enneng Motor Co., Ltd. focuses on permanent magnet motor design and production. The company’s products include:

    • Low-speed, high-torque PMSMs for conveyors in mining.

    • Constant-speed PMSMs for textile and fiber equipment.

    • Direct-drive PMSMs for compressors and pumps.

    Their motors are used in coal mines, tire plants, oil fields, and water treatment sites. By combining advanced design with rare-earth materials, Enneng delivers motors that meet IE3–IE4 efficiency, run cooler, and last longer.

    Looking at torque, losses, and materials, the case for the magnet motor is strong. It starts with higher torque, wastes less energy, and uses materials that allow smaller and lighter designs.

    Induction motors still serve many needs, but in industries where energy cost and uptime are key, PMSMs are often the smarter pick. For companies exploring this path, Qingdao Enneng Motor Co., Ltd. provides tailored motor solutions that bring efficiency and durability into real-world production.

    FAQs

    Q1: Why does a magnet motor use less energy than an induction motor?
    Because it doesn’t need current in the rotor. Permanent magnets supply the field directly, cutting losses.

    Q2: Can a magnet motor handle heavy loads at startup?
    Yes. PMSMs offer high torque from the first moment, without pulling high inrush current.

    Q3: What materials are used inside a magnet motor?
    They usually use rare-earth magnets like NdFeB, which are small but very strong.

    Q4: Is maintenance easier with a magnet motor?
    It is. With fewer parts that wear down and cooler operation, service needs are reduced.

    Q5: Where do industries use magnet motors the most?
    They are common in compressors, textile machines, conveyors, pumps, and water treatment systems.

    RELATED PRODUCT